Skip to main content
Serving Waynesboro and Fishersville with the Best Delivery Food

Are you ready for the best pizza in Waynesboro?

New Brother’s Pizza, Pasta and Subs has proudly served Waynesboro and Fishersville for the last 16 years.

Our locally-owned restaurant specializes in pizza, pasta and subs. In fact, we bake over 30,000 pizzas each year! Thousands of customers trust our experienced team for some of the best tasting food in the area.

Why does our food taste so good?

At New Brother’s Pizza, our team uses only the finest ingredients to make each dish. When you combine the best ingredients with nearly two decades of culinary experience, the final result is great tasting food.

We offer take-out and delivery options to both residential and business addresses. Call us today to place your order!

French Fries

$2.99 / $5.25

Choose small or large.

Cheese Fries

$5.75

Served with ranch.

Cheese Fries

$6.50

With bacon.

Onion Rings

$4.49 / $6.99

Choose small or large.

Chicken Tenders (3)

$5.75

Served with honey mustard.

Chicken Tenders (3) with Fries

$6.99

Served with honey mustard.

Fried Pickles (5)

$5.99

Served with ranch.

Breaded Fried Mushrooms

$6.99

Served with ranch.

Jalapeño Poppers (8)

$8.99

Served with ranch.

Mozzarella Sticks (8)

$8.60

Served with marinara.

Garlic Bread

$4.25

Served with marinara.

Garlic Bread with Cheese

$5.99

Served with marinara.

Fried Calamari

$8.99

Served with marinara.

Bread Sticks (8)

$6.99

Served with marinara.

Bread Sticks (8) with Cheese

$8.25

Served with marinara.

Martin’s Potato Chips

$1.35

Choose from regular or BBQ.

Appetizer Sampler

$9.99

3 chicken wings, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 jalapeño poppers, 5 breaded fried mushrooms with ranch, bleu cheese & marinara sauce for dipping.

Meatballs (4)

$8.99

With marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

Extra Dipping Sauce

$0.75

10 Count

$10.99

20 Count

$20.50

30 Count

$29.99

50 Count

$49.49

Choose from Mild or Hot Chicken Wings (lightly breaded, no sauce). Add your favorite sauce (BBQ, Buffalo, Mango Habanero, Brother’s Extra Hot)

Celery available upon request.

Garden Salad

$7.49

A mixture of fresh vegetables, lettuce, green peppers, onions, olives, carrots, mushrooms, cucumber, tomatoes & a choice of dressing.

Grilled Chicken Salad

$9.49

Grilled chicken over our fresh garden salad and a choice of dressing.

Chef Salad

$9.49

Strips of ham, turkey, cheese and sliced hard boiled egg served over our fresh garden salad and a choice of dressing.

Tuna Salad

$9.99

Freshly prepared tuna salad over our fresh garden salad and a choice of dressing.

BLT Salad

$9.25

Strips of bacon, over fresh lettuce and tomato with choice of dressing.

Greek Salad

$8.99

Feta cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, fire roasted red pepper, cucumber and Greek dressing on the side.

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

$9.49

Grilled chicken served over fresh Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, imported pecorino Romano cheese and Caesar dressing on the side.

Spinach Salad

$9.25

Spinach, sliced hard-boiled egg, bacon, tomatoes, onions, raisins and walnuts. Served with raspberry vinaigrette on the side.

Antipasto Salad

$9.75

Ham, salami, cucumber, tomatoes, black olives, roasted red peppers, aged provolone cheese and pepperoncini peppers over fresh iceberg lettuce. Served with our house oil and vinegar dressing on the side.

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$9.49

Fried chicken breast tossed with spicy buffalo sauce. Served with iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, pepperoncini peppers, bleu cheese crumbles and a choice of dressing.

Complement any salad with:

  • Grilled Shrimp (6) – $4.75
  • Grilled or Crispy Chicken – $2.99

Salad Dressings
Ranch, House Italian, Oil & Vinegar, Honey Mustard, 1000 Island, Bleu Cheese, French, Raspberry Vinaigrette

All dressings are served on the side.

New York Style Pizza

Pizzas are priced from small (10″), medium (14″) and large (16″).

Cheese Pizza

$7.49 / $10.49 / $12.49

Choose from our regular or specialty toppings.

Regular Toppings

$1.25 / $1.90 / $2.20

Garlic, Spinach, Broccoli, Salami, Ricotta, Black Olives, Ham, Bacon, Onions, Meatballs, Mushrooms, Pepperoni, Anchovies, Pineapple, Sausage, Jalapeño Peppers, Green Peppers, Fresh Tomatoes, Extra Cheese, Banana Peppers, Chicken, Ground Beef

Specialty Toppings

$1.75 / $2.49 / $2.99

Feta Cheese, Italian Sausage, Roasted Red Peppers, Kalamata Olives, Gyro Meat, Eggplant

Sicilian

$16.99

Thick crust, large only.

Specialty Pizzas

Pizzas are priced from small (10″), medium (14″) and large (16″).

Stuffed Pizza

$15.49 / $19.49 / $22.99

Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sausage, ham, salami and pizza sauce. Glazed with seasoned garlic sauce sprinkled with imported pecorino romano cheese.

Supreme Pizza

$12.25 / $16.25 / $19.25

Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions and mushrooms.

Vegetarian Pizza

$11.75 / $15.75 / $18.25

Mozzarella cheese, fresh tomatoes, onions, broccoli, a touch of garlic and herbs. No pizza sauce.

BBQ Chicken & Bacon Pizza

$12.25 / $16.49 / $18.49

Mozzarella cheese, BBQ sauce, topped with all-white chicken, bacon and onions.

Meat Lovers Pizza

$12.49 / $16.75 / $19.99

Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, ham, salami, bacon and sausage.

White Pizza

$11.75 / $15.75 / $18.49

Mozzarella cheese, ricotta, garlic, spinach, fresh tomatoes and Italian herbs. No pizza sauce.

Hawaiian Pizza

$11.49 / $15.49 / $17.99

Mozzarella cheese, ham and pineapple. No pizza sauce.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$11.75 / $15.75 / $17.99

Mozzarella cheese, buffalo sauce, topped with all-white chicken, black pepper and onions.

Mediterranean Pizza

$12.25 / $16.49 / $18.49

Minced garlic, extra virgin olive oil, fresh spinach leaves, roasted red peppers, kalamata olives, feta cheese and mozzarella cheese. No pizza sauce.

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

$13.49 / $17.49 / $20.49

Chopped steak, onions, green peppers, American and mozzarella cheese with pizza sauce.

Chicken Alfredo

$12.25 / $16.49 / $18.49

Mozzarella cheese, chicken, spinach, bacon and Alfredo sauce.

Baked to perfection. Glazed with seasoned garlic sauce, sprinkled with imported pecorino Romano cheese and served with our signature marinara sauce for dipping. Additional toppings $0.99 (small) & $1.59 (large) each.

Stromboli

$10.49 / $14.99

Choose small or large. Filled with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, ham, salami, green peppers and pizza sauce.

Steak Stromboli

$10.99 / $15.99

Choose small or large. Filled with mozzarella cheese, steak and pizza sauce.

Veggie Stromboli

$9.99 / $14.99

Choose small or large. Filled with mozzarella cheese, spinach, onions, green peppers, black olives, mushrooms and pizza sauce.

Cheese Calzone

$9.99 / $14.99

Filled with mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese.

Ham & Cheese Calzone

$10.49 / $14.99

Filled with mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese and ham.

Spinach & Cheese Calzone

$10.49 / $14.99

Filled with mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese and spinach.

Served with homemade garlic bread.

Spaghetti, Linguini or Ziti

$9.25-$10.99

with Marinara ($9.25), with Alfredo Sauce ($10.99), with Meat Sauce or Mushrooms ($10.25), with Meatballs (2) or Sausage ($10.75), with Olive Oil & Garlic ($9.49).

Meat Lasagna

$11.75

Layers of pasta, ground beef, assorted cheeses. Topped with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.

Baked Ziti

$10.75

Ziti mixed with ricotta cheese and marinara sauce. Smothered with mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection.

Stuffed Shells

$10.99

4 pasta shells filled with assorted cheese and spices. Topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection.

Baked Ravioli

$10.75

Your choice of cheese or meat filled pasta pillows, smothered in our homemade tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection.

Eggplant Parmigiana

$11.99

Deep-fried, sliced eggplant smothered in our homemade tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection. Served with your choice of spaghetti or a small house salad.

Tri-Color Tortellini

$11.99

Tri-Color cheese tortellini with peas, spinach and tomatoes. Served in a cream rose sauce.

Complement any pasta with:

  • Grilled shrimp (6) – $4.75
  • Grilled chicken – $2.99

Add a small house salad to any pasta or baked dish for $2.49.

Served with homemade garlic bread.

Chicken Parmigiana

$14.49

Prime chicken lightly breaded, topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection and served with your choice of spaghetti or small house salad.

Shrimp Scampi

$16.49

10 Peeled and de-veined large shrimp, sautéed in white wine, lemon and garlic butter sauce. Served over a bed of linguini.

Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken & Broccoli

$14.49

Thick fettuccine noodles smothered in a rich creamy alfredo sauce, topped with grilled chicken and freshly steamed broccoli.

Shrimp Alfredo

$16.49

10 Large peeled and de-veined shrimp, with Fettuccine pasta, freshly steamed broccoli, smothered in a rich creamy alfredo sauce.

Shrimp Fra Diavolo

$16.49

10 Large peeled and de-veined large shrimp, sautéed in garlic and a blend of spicy seasonings, smothered with our homemade tomato sauce and served over a bed of linguini.

Add a small house salad to any entree for $2.49.

Served on a toasted Kaiser roll. At your request, we can add lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pickle, mayo, ketchup & mustard at no extra charge.

Hamburger

$5.99

Cheeseburger

$6.25

Mushroom Swiss Burger

$6.49

Bacon Swiss Burger

$6.75

Add fries and a 12oz drink to any burger for just $2.49 extra.

At your request, we can add lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo, green peppers or black olives to any sub at no additional charge. Whole wheat bread available upon request.

Cheese Steak

$7.25

Tender seasoned steak and American cheese.

Special Cheese Steak

$7.75

Tender seasoned steak, American cheese, grilled onions, mushrooms and green peppers.

Chicken Cheese Steak

$7.25

Chicken steak and American cheese.

Special Chicken Cheese Steak-

$7.75

Tender seasoned chicken steak, American cheese, grilled onions, mushrooms and green peppers.

Add fries and a 12oz drink to any sub for just $2.49 extra.

At your request, we can add lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo, green peppers or black olives to any sub at no additional charge. Whole wheat bread available upon request.

Italian Sub

$7.49

Served hot or cold. Ham, salami, capicola, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes with oil and vinegar.

Turkey & Provolone Cheese

$7.75

Served hot or cold.

Ham & Provolone Cheese

$7.49

Served hot or cold.

Tuna & Provolone Cheese

$7.99

Served hot.

Roast Beef & Provolone Cheese

$7.99

Served hot or cold.

Grilled Chicken & Provolone Cheese

$7.75

Served hot or cold.

Club Sub

$8.25

Served hot or cold. Ham, turkey, roast beef, bacon and provolone cheese.

Vegetarian Sub

$7.25

Served hot or cold. Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, olives, onions, green peppers and mushrooms.

Add fries and a 12oz drink to any sub for just $2.49 extra.

Whole wheat bread available upon request.

Pizza Steak Sub

$7.49

Tender seasoned steak, tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection.

Italian Sausage Sub

$7.99

Served hot. Sautéed Italian sausage, onions, green peppers and tomato sauce.

Meatball Sub

$7.75

Served hot. Meatballs smothered with sauce and mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection.

Chicken Parmigiana

$7.75

Served hot. Breaded chicken breast smothered with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection.

Eggplant Parmigiana

$7.99

Served hot. Sliced eggplant smothered with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection.

Add fries and a 12oz drink to any sub for just $2.49 extra.

All sandwiches come with your choice of regular or BBQ chips (excludes Grilled Cheese).

Gyro

$9.49

Served with chips. Lamb meat, feta cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and sautéed onions wrapped in a pita. Served with cucumber sauce on the side.

Chicken Pita

$8.99

Served with chips. Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, mayo and ranch dressing wrapped in a pita.

Grilled Cheese

$3.75

American cheese on white bread.

Reuben

$8.99

Served with chips. Thin sliced corn beef, sauerkraut, thousand island dressing, melted provolone cheese and served on toasted rye bread.

BLT Sandwich

$7.99

Served with chips. Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes served on toasted white bread.

All Croissant Sandwiches come with Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo & your choice of regular or BBQ chips.

Cheese Choices: Mozzarella, Provolone, American, Swiss

Club Croissant

$8.49

Ham, turkey, bacon and your choice of cheese.

Tuna Croissant

$8.75

Fresh homemade tuna and your choice of cheese.

Grilled Chicken Croissant

$8.49

Tender grilled chicken breast and your choice of cheese.

Ham Croissant

$8.49

Sliced ham and your choice of cheese.

Turkey Croissant

$8.49

Sliced turkey breast and your choice of cheese.

For kids 12 and under.

Hamburger

$6.49

Served with fries.

Grilled Cheese

$5.49

Served with fries.

Chicken Nuggets

$5.49

Served with fries.

Spaghetti

$6.99

Served with marinara sauce and garlic bread.

We carry Coke products.

12oz Can

$1.35

20oz Bottle

$2.39

2 Liter Bottle

$2.99

Vitamin Water

$2.49

XXX (Pomegranate) and Essential (Orange)

Chocolate Lovin’ Cake

$5.49

Limoncello Mascarpone Cake

$4.99

New York Cheese Cake

$4.99

Add strawberries for $0.50

Cannoli

$3.49

All menu prices are subject to change without notice. Prices DO NOT include tax or delivery fee.

Customer Reviews

“

I have NEVER had delivery where it felt like it just came out of the oven...the food was terrific and definitely recommended the cheesy garlic bread.

Brittany R.
“

The pizzas were amazing. The sampler was good. Really liked the wings and deep fried mushrooms. We will order again.

Lindsey K.
“

Best pizza around! I have tried multiple pizzerias, most have a good crust or great sauce, but they have it all.

Daniel S.
“

Excellent! The lady who took my phone order was very friendly and sweet. The food was delivered hot and fresh, and ahead of schedule. The pizza is delicious, the wings are great...

Yvonne Y.
“

My daughter and I both enjoyed our subs. My wife's calzone was just plain awesome. I'm definitely getting one next time we order...Service was friendly and the price was reasonable.

Frank D.
“

We have lived in this area for 2 years and had never tried this place. Tonight we decided to try it and can I say OMG!!! The steak and cheese and the wings we ordered were the best we have ever had in this area.

Toby R.
“

Consistently delicious food with friendly service. Prices are very reasonable. Our favorite place for Italian.

Judy B.
“

Definitely hands down best food in Waynesboro! I will not get pizza or subs from anywhere but them. Amazing customer service as well.

Aries Q.

Contact New Brothers Pizza

Address

2006 Jefferson Hwy
Fishersville, VA 22939

Across from the Preston L Yancey Fire Station on Route 250

Payment Options

We accept cash and all major credit cards, but we do not accept personal checks. Gift certificates are also available.

Add sales tax to all prices. Prices subject to change without notice.

Close Menu